Share this with someone who needs it
Follow Jonathan Arenburg
For thoughtful conversations about mental health, modern life, human biology, and what it means to stay connected in a disconnected world.
You’re anxious. A little fearful. Worried about what to say around others lest you make yet another enemy.
I can remember a time when an opposing opinion was met with understanding — and when there was a well-defined line in the sand when it came to name-calling and yelling. In other words, people were less anxious when I was a young man, and because of that, people were more tolerant of difference.
Today, it feels like people have been worn down by a nonstop barrage of engineered division. For some, it hurts so much that it provokes an immediate and intense response. It’s as though the entire world has grown up in an environment where the default defense mechanism is simply to be defensive.
I’ve written before about how this constant tension shows up quietly in everyday life, especially in The Quiet Weight Behind “I’m Fine”. We carry more than we realize — and it often leaks out through our conversations.
I know that environment well. I grew up in places where I felt like I had to defend every move I made.
You might be thinking, “That’s a tough family unit to grow up in.” And you’d be partly right. But that was only part of the story.
Growing Up in Constant Defense Mode
Elementary school was an absolutely brutal time in my life. To be fair, I made it worse by acting out regularly. If I wasn’t busy being the proverbial class clown, I was roaring like a lion on my way to yet another trip to the office to “explain myself.”
There’s no doubt I was a troubled kid, even back then. But I was also placed into a program casually referred to as “slow learners.” Years later, after a diagnosis of depression, I began to understand that this was likely the source of many of my struggles at eight years old.
I’ve shared more openly about those lifelong battles in The Road to Mental Wellness — particularly how not being seen or understood early on shapes how we relate to the world as adults.
What that little boy really wanted was a chance to be a “normal learner.” I only wish they had known back then that I wasn’t throwing my homework away because I was lazy or incapable. I was just unbelievably bored — and I didn’t see the point.
We’re Seeing Our Friends Less — and Our Nervous Systems Are Paying the Price
Canadians are spending less time with friends than ever before. Not because connection has lost its value, but because modern life has quietly made it harder to sustain.
Keep reading
What I Wish I Had Known Then
Fast-forward to today, decades after that little fella felt he had to defend himself over everything, and I’d like to think I’ve learned a thing or two.
One of the most important lessons I’ve learned is this: an early, deeply embedded defensive stance is incredibly hard to shake.
Just as important is the fact that it creates conflict everywhere you go. Intolerance and insistence that you’re right often take hold because, growing up, no one believed you. So as an adult, you become louder — more passionate — about the things you do know, especially when you believe you’re correct.
This is one of the central ideas I explore in Wired to Be Human — how our nervous systems, shaped early by environment and threat, don’t simply disappear when we grow up. They come with us into conversations, disagreements, and relationships, quietly steering how we react long before logic has a say.
This pattern shows up clearly in modern culture, where reaction has replaced reflection. I explore this further in Mental Health and the Digital Division, where outrage is rewarded and listening is quietly discouraged.
But it’s the bridge-burning effect that I want to focus on here.
When you don’t give people space to have their say, they’re far less likely to want to stay connected to you.
We’re Not Anti-Social — We’re Burned Out
The science is clear — our brains are wired for connection. From the oxytocin that bonds us to the prefrontal cortex that helps us regulate emotion, human biology depends on social interaction. Yet modern life isolates us more than ever, leaving stress unchecked and loneliness widespread.
The Cost of Constant Reactivity
More and more of us are reacting to one another instead of listening. As a result, defensiveness is becoming commonplace. And if that weren’t enough, confidence has quietly morphed into certainty — the kind that leaves no room for dialogue.
When everyone is yelling, people don’t lean in. They shut down. They feel numb. Divided.
This is the same nervous-system takeover I’ve described in When PTSD Speaks — where protection becomes the priority and connection falls away.
So what’s the antidote?
The Antidote: Less Talking, More Listening
When we keep our mouths closed and our ears open, we leave space. Space for people to feel safe. Space for calm. And when people feel safe, they’re far more willing to reciprocate.
Let me explain.
My sister and I grew up always on guard — responding to one another in attack-and-defense mode. That dynamic followed us well into adulthood. Even into our forties, we were still blowing up at each other based on two things:
- A long, reactive history
- The power of assumption
Talk about walking on eggshells.
That dance — shaped by teenage experiences and environmental stress — finally came to a productive head a few weeks ago. We sat down and finally heard each other.
What Healing Conversations Feel Like
Beyond validating how we each saw our relationship, something else happened — something I had noticed in others but never thought I’d experience so directly with my sister.
Peace.
That calm, grounded feeling that comes from a healing conversation.
It echoed something I explored in Why Being Noticed Matters for Mental Health — how being truly seen regulates the nervous system in ways arguments never can.
Going forward, we decided that being kinder matters more. Fifty may be later in life, but it definitely isn’t too late. And for that, I’m grateful.
Why This Matters Right Now
This is how I feel about the current state of the world’s communication style.
If only we could truly hear what the other person is saying. If only we could acknowledge it without letting it ruin the bond.
Most people are tense right now. A little anxious. A little helpless. I see this pattern repeatedly across The Road to Mental Wellness, including in Allostatic Load and PTSD — where chronic stress quietly reshapes how we react to one another.
If we cool the conversation, calm will follow. And calm has a way of spreading.
You can reach a better place — one rooted in understanding and shaped by kindness, especially with the people who matter most.
I’m rooting for you.
— Jonathan
Join the conversation
If this resonated—or challenged you—I’d genuinely like to hear your perspective. Thoughtful disagreement and lived experience are welcome.
Scroll down to the comments below. Please keep it respectful—this is a space for honest, human conversation.